Reflections on Canadian Identity: What the 2025 Federal Election Reveals About Our Collective Story

On Monday night (April 28, 2025), Canadians didn’t just cast votes—they told a story. About who we are, what we value, and where we believe we’re going.

As the results of the 2025 Federal Election rolled in, I found myself thinking less about seats and more about symbols. Less about the politics, and more about the narrative we’re crafting together as a nation. Because at its core, an election is just another kind of storytelling—one that plays out across platforms, debates, doorsteps, and digital comment sections. And like all stories, it reveals something deep about the people who choose to tell it.

Moments like this have long inspired Canadian artists to interrogate identity, power, and place. Whether it’s Kent Monkman subverting colonial narratives or filmmakers capturing quiet rebellion, the work that emerges from cultural tension often becomes timeless.

Kent Monkman, “The Madhouse” (2020). Image via Sotheby’s.

The Election as a Mirror

This year’s election was historic— a shift in leadership that saw all major parties change at the top, a resurgence of voter engagement and the emergence of new voices on the political stage.

Justin Trudeau stepped down as Prime Minister, making way for Mark Carney to step into the Liberal leadership – Carney led the party to a minority government win. Meanwhile, Pierre Poilievre gained ground for the Conservatives, solidifying their dominance in Alberta and Saskatchewan—but lost his own seat in Carleton. The Bloc Québécois saw a drop in seats but retained just enough influence to affect the balance of power. The NDP, facing its own steep decline, lost official party status, prompting Jagmeet Singh’s resignation as leader.

2025 Canadian Federal Election Results. Image via Wikimedia Commons.

The Liberal Party hold a minority government victory, securing 169 seats—just shy of the 172 needed for a majority. What’s more surprising is that this actually came to fruition; many political sources and publications have stated that the Conservatives (or Tories as they love to be called 😉 ), under Poilievre, should have won the election but Carney’s leadership played a pivotal role in reshaping the Liberal’s fortunes. In the end, the Conservatives won 144 seats, with Poilievre notably losing his own seat in Carleton. The NDP faced significant losses, securing only 7 seats and as mentioned, Singh’s resignation as party leader.

  1. “Canada’s Trudeau survives no-confidence vote in latest test for his gov’t” – Al Jazeera
  2. “Canada’s election, explained via poutine” – The Washington Post
  3. “Mark Carney Wins Canada Election, Capping Dramatic Turnaround for Liberals” – The Wall Street Journal

But beyond all the numbers and headlines, what resonated with me was the underlying tone.

The election served as a cultural mirror. The language of the campaigns, the concerns raised at town halls, and the platforms that gained traction told us that Canadians are wrestling with identity, equity, safety, and hope.

In film, we’d call this a turning point. The moment where the protagonist must decide whether to change, resist, or retreat. And I’d argue that Canada—like a character in a compelling drama—is right in the middle of that scene.

Among the many reflections I’ve come across, some of the most thoughtful have captured the nuance of this moment through unity and empathy. They point out that this election wasn’t just a division of geography, but of generations, values, and rhetoric—and that the real path forward lies in unity and empathy.

Everyone is entitled to their belief and their vote, but regardless of how they voted, they are our neighbor.

Creativity in the Shadow of Politics

Elections don’t happen in a vacuum. They shape how we create, fund, and distribute art. They influence the stories that get amplified—and those that get buried.

As someone who built a platform rooted in cultural critique and creative expression, I’ve always believed that artists have a responsibility to pay attention. Not necessarily to be political in the traditional sense, but to be attuned. To reflect, to question, to push. What we create in response to the world matters—and this election may mark a shift in tone for many Canadian creators.

Whether you’re a filmmaker, a writer, a painter, or simply someone who consumes art with intention, you’ve probably felt this undercurrent before: that moment when politics start to bleed into the palette. For me, I think back to films that captured national identity in flux—like Gangs of New York, Incendies, Waltz with Bashir or District 9. Granted, District 9 is a sci-fi set in South Africa, but it does a fantastic job exposing the legacy of apartheid.

A country’s soul is often best understood through its art.

What Artists and Thinkers Can Do Next

So what now?

We make things. We stay present.

We interpret this moment and give it texture. Whether we agree with the outcome or feel disappointed, we don’t go quiet. Creativity is resistance, but it’s also restoration.

timotheories ethos has always been about uncovering truths through culture—digging into film, art, and ideas not just for entertainment, but for connection. And this is one of those times when connection is crucial. We need the dreamers and the realists, the critics and the community-builders, the hopeful and the heartbroken. Because storytelling doesn’t end at the polls. It starts again the next day.

Films That Speak to Our Political Soul

Confession time: I haven’t seen most of these films coming up.

But in reflecting on this election, I found myself wondering—how has Canadian cinema captured moments like this? What stories of resistance, quiet rebellion, or cultural reckoning have we already told?

So I did what any artist would do: I dug in.

The list below isn’t a list of films I’ve mastered—yet. It’s a set of culturally significant Canadian works that I’m adding to my own Watch List. Stories that speak to identity, resilience, and the subtle ways people push back against systems, silence, or expectations.

If you’re curious too, maybe this is your invitation to watch with me:

  • Antigone (2019, dir. Sophie Deraspe) – A bold reimagining of the Greek classic, rooted in a teenage girl’s fight for justice in Quebec’s immigration system.
  • Sleeping Giant (2015, dir. Andrew Cividino) – A quiet but potent exploration of masculinity, grief, and adolescent rebellion in Northern Ontario.
  • Meditation Park (2017, dir. Mina Shum) – A Vancouver grandmother begins quietly reclaiming her autonomy after decades of self-sacrifice.
  • The Body Remembers When the World Broke Open (2019, dirs. Tailfeathers & Hepburn) – A real-time portrait of Indigenous womanhood, class divides, and unexpected compassion.
  • Firecrackers (2018, dir. Jasmin Mozaffari) – Two teenage girls on the edge of adulthood push against the limits of control and small-town life.

These aren’t loud stories—but they’re full of power. And maybe, like this election, they remind us that the undercurrents matter just as much as the headlines.

theories Summarized

The 2025 Federal Election is now part of Canada’s cultural archive. A chapter closed, but far from the end. What comes next—how we respond, create, and relate—matters just as much. Maybe even more.

So I’ll keep watching, writing, and wondering. And I hope you will too. Let’s continue to make sense of the world together—one story at a time.

What did the 2025 election mean to you? What story do you see unfolding in your community, your creativity, or your own life? Let’s talk in the comments.

Selling Your Heart Out (Dave Von Bieker, preview interview pt 2)

Do we all get to be who we decide to portray ourselves as on screen or in the media? I’d like to believe that it’s possible. But more importantly, I wonder if we can ever live up to the moral ideals we establish about our creative touch.

Making art is extremely difficult to sustain and it takes a lot of personal sacrifice if you really do hope to make it for a life time. Whether your medium is music, painting, design, fashion, photography, video, dance or any other combination of forms, it’s challenging road, filled with dues paid and money earned.

And a more common theme on everyone’s lips is the notion of burning out or fading away with time. The age old struggle of the creative professional – to be completely bohemian or a corporate sell-out. These polarizing terms exist for reason though, and I happen to believe that both are valid ways of looking at this as a career. This is where the theory comes in; if you want to truly be happy, you need to embrace both in some regard. That’s why it’s important to wrestle with the dichotomy of self versus the selfless.

Yes, you shouldn’t compare yourself to others, but relating to what those who have come before and have found success is an invaluable exercise. You might learn something by breaking apart a Kanye West song, recreating a Rembrant, or spending some time with 1927 movie classic Metropolis.

It’s a continual sacrifice. I give a lot for my art and to make it, so it seems crazy to me that I wouldn’t it to be heard by as many people as possible

Dave Von Bieker

I had so much fun talking with local music genius Von Bieker, that I decided to give another preview interview. I know, I know, I promised a full length interview, but this way you get even more content, and I can further craft his story in a meaningful way for you. Time for some more bow-tie rock to haunt your heart.

Enjoy creative cuties!

theories Summarized

Everything I do artistically is an expression of my ideals. Is this a true statement?

It’s an excellent question to ask yourself dear readers, and if you did, please like and share the video, leave me some comments and I’ll share them on social media. Maybe some new theories will unfold in the process.

Coming up next, a review on the new Young Fathers record, so please check back in tomorrow evening for more theories! You won’t be disappointed.

Tim!

Better Be Starting Something (Our Lady Peace, Somethingness review)

Fifteen years ago, I had an opportunity to see Our Lady Peace live at a festival and while I took it upon myself to watch them, I never really appreciated it. They were alternative rockers in an open sea of rock and roll, and their music was good, but not great, in my limited opinion.

mp3s hadn’t completely overtaken the musical landscape just yet, but it was becoming more common for smaller musicians to get attention, and more and more Canadian musicians were cropping up. 

Now, after twenty-six years of activity, are they still relevant?

 

Our Lady Peace – Somethingness

released February 23, 2018
****** 6/10

Our Lady Peace, sometimes known as OLP, are a Canadian rock group that have their roots firmly planted in Toronto. Headed by founding member Raine Maida (vocals, guitar), and longstanding members Steve Mazur (guitar) and Duncan Coutts (vocals, bass), Somethingness is their ninth studio album, and the first since the departure of twenty year drummer Jeremy Taggart, and new comer Jason Pierce.

As I mentioned previously, I’ve seen this group live before, but I have not been much of a fan in their lifetime. This might have stemmed from defiance on my part, refusing to vote with my money simply because a rock group was Canadian, but as I look back on their catalogue, it occurs to me, that these guys really have contributed to the current rock landscape. Maybe not as influencers, necessarily, but by association with with major acts – Foo Fighters, Goo Goo Dolls, Stone Temple Pilots, and Big Wreck all come to mind.

It’s not a particularly innovative album, but as Maida states on opening track Head Down, “I’ll find my place in the sun,” which a mid-tempo song, and a good indicator of the pace to expect for the majority of the record.

Embracing their skill with guitars and penchant for coded lyrics, songs like Ball Of A Poet and Hiding Place for Hearts demonstrate that sound well, and are welcome additions to the album. What I found most surprising of all was how great of a job Drop Me In The Water does of demonstrating the groups strengths, and showing a new generation why their sound was beloved in the 1990s and as a great alternative to the dance-rock and indie folk of the day. Nice To Meet You‘s lyrics are uplifting and topical.

When we get to the last two songs, Let Me Live Again and Last Train, it takes a bit of effort to become reinvested, but Last Train is the most experimental of any of the songs on the record, and a strong point to end on.

 

Pros: As stated already, singles Nice To Meet You and Drop Me in the Water are excellent, as they raise the emotional bar enough to resonate with a broader audience, and they are technically sound too. But best of all is

Cons: Towards the back half of the record, we listen to some even more subdued tracks – Missing Pieces and Falling into Place. These songs feel at odds with the emotional tone set up in the first half of the record.

Runtime: 33 minutes

Points of Interest: OLP initially decided to split the album up into two volumes, releasing the first EP back in August 2017, but after some consideration a full-length album dropped February 23, 2018 which is the subject of this review.

I wish Last Train would have been an opening track, and influenced more of the record. To be considered as a final thought, is frustrating, to be perfectly honest. I would’ve probably written this album off with out it, Drop Me In The Water, and Nice To Meet You in the mix. I hope this is the start of something, rather then a middling effort at the end of a career.

theories Summarized

At the end of the day, I’m not sure I can fully endorse this album for the average music fan. It’s great if you already know about Our Lady Peace, but if you are looking to try them out, I would direct you to Naveed or one of the other first four albums in a heartbeat upon personal reflection.

That said, I do have a Canadian album that I can easily and happily support. The sophomore effort from k-os, an artist who should be considered a national treasure at this point. And if you don’t believe me, I brought Brendon along to show you the finer points of the record.

What a gem he is. I’ll leave it up to you to decide if I’m referring to my co-host or the artist in question! For now, I’ll listen to The Love Song on repeat. 

And remember, if you liked what you saw, and/or enjoyed what you read, please click on the like button, and even better, subscribe to the channel and my mailing list! I’ll be back tomorrow with a film review on Three Billboards Outside of Ebbing, Missouri. A film which deserved more then it got at the Academy Awards. I have a few theories on what happened…

Tim!

Phasers Set To Stun (Dear Rouge, PHASES review)

I will totally agree that there is an ebb and flow to life. We all experience highs and lows, and whatever exists in-between, but on the surface, it’s never quite so obvious that the flow is much more internal then could ever be demonstrated. To put it another way, transitions happen constantly within our thought processes.

 

Dear Rouge – PHASES

released March 9, 2018
******** 8/10

Dear Rouge is an award-winning Canadian alternative and dance rock duo, comprised of husband and wife, Drew and Danielle McTaggart. They’ve been active since 2012, and initially met while touring under different bands. It wasn’t until after they had been married that they began the Dear Rouge brand. In case you were wondering (and I very much was!), the band name is a play on words – Danielle’s home town is Red Deer, Alberta.

PHASES is their sophomore album, released just three years after the critically successful Black to Gold. Returning this time with a more refined sound, and influenced by the places it was recorded at (Toronto, Montreal, Nashville, Vancouver and New York), the McTaggarts set out to produce an album which doesn’t actually innovate much on what came before, but instead feels more intentional with it’s themes and tonal choices.

It’s all very cheery and hopeful, except for when it’s not, and even when Dear Rouge has committed one way or the other, the other side comes through to create a feeling of warmth. This is created to great effect within the first two tracks. Wicked Thing is very much a bright song with a hopeful resonance, and yet, there is a tone underneath that loving affection can easily turn into obsession. And then that theme of obsession is more prominently stated on Live Through The Night, but that song is overtly dark and mysterious. The dance between darkness and pop continues on Stolen Days, an aching callback to youth, not knowing any better, growing up and maturing, and is very much a tribute to Drew’s late cousin.

The singles Boys & Blondes, and Modern Shakedown make up the core of the album’s hype machine, and deservedly so. They are both essential dance-rock with catchy lyrics, heavy on the synth and bass and explosive chorus’. Boys & Blondes has feminist themes and Modern Shakedown is super dark.

It’s a living breathing album, which was desrcribed by it’s creators as full of grit and gloss, and I think that’s a pretty apt description.

Pros: Each song is really and truly exciting to listen to and gives us an opportunity to pick up a torch and fight for the cause of indie pop-rock. If you really want to get a taste for this album listen to Live Through The Night, Little By Little, and The Clearing. Darker nights of pop there have been not.

Cons: Though the tone and quality of production is consistent throughout, there is very little variation from song to song, which makes it difficult to know where you are at any given point, and having to give pause takes you out of the mood.

Runtime: 37 minutes

Points of Interest: Dear Rouge spent the better part of 2016 and 2017 touring while they were writing and recording their follow-up album. Tawgs Salter, Sterling Fox, and Hot Hot Heat frontman, Steve Bays, all helped produce the record.

If you really want to compare it to other acts of today, PHASES can easily knock down the doors of other dance-rock and dance-punk progenitors. I’m looking at you The Killers, DFA, and LCD Soundsystem. Heck, even synth-pop and indie darlings like Metric, Tove Lo, and La Roux should be concerned. Dear Rouge are trendsetters and clearly cutting up the Spotify charts.

theories Summarized

Should you listen to this album? Yeah, I think it’s worth a listen or five. Don’t get me wrong, I love some Taylor Swift and Lady Gaga, but Canadian music content always feels a little bit more authentic and inventive with it’s presentation. And tastemakers are always so fashionable to boot. My theory, of course.

And speaking of tastemakers, I’ve got this really cool review lined up with Brendon Greene on the classic hip hop album from the now retired Beastie Boys. That’s right! Licensed To Ill is going to get some love this week, whether you’re hearing it for the first time, or it’s been on your brain since the 1980s, this is seriously fun music, and influential too.

I greatly appreciate that you took the time to read this review, and I hope it helps you to decide to listen to it. And if you’ve already heard it before, I trust my thoughts affirmed how you felt, one way or another! And what did you think of Brendon and my Sound Culture video review? Licensed to Ill is an instrumental hip hop record, and well worth a listen! And remember, if you liked what you saw, and/ior enjoyed what you read, please click on the like button, and even better, subscribe to the channel and my mailing list! I’ll be back tomorrow with a film review on The Disaster Artist. There’ll be more theories!

Tim!

Ukelele Anthems For Two (Vance Joy, Nation of Two review)

Not every album needs to be a chest bumper or a call to arms. Sometimes it’s nice for music to be nice, and reflective. A thread between two hearts, for starters.

 

Vance Joy – Nation of Two

released February 23, 2018
******* 7/10

Vance Gabriel Keogh, better known by his stage name, Vance Joy, is an Australian singer and songwriter. He signed a five-album deal with Atlantic records back in 2013, and shortly thereafter, released his instant success, Dream Your Life Away, hopping on the back of The 1989 World Tour that Taylor Swift planned that year. Everyone and their mother knows Riptide at this point, and somehow Joy managed to ride the waves of that album for four years without anyone really noticing. Pun intended.

Lucky for us though, because his sophomore effort, Nation of Two, was worth the wait. It’s not an amazing album, but there’s something to it. Featuring the singles, Lay It on Me, Like Gold, We’re Going Home and more, Joy has managed to do even better the second time around. Garnering fans and swooning hearts all the same.

What I love most about this album, as I’ve said in previous reviews, is that it’s a concept record – Nation of Two tells the story of a couple who’s world is centred around their bedroom, their car, and other memories they share collectively. Even though it’s similar in tone to his debut album, and doesn’t push strongly in one direction or the other, I actually think it makes it a stronger record, and gives this one a pass. Love isn’t always about ups and downs, fights and makeup sex, it’s a consistent feeling of companionship and connection. Flowing from one situation to the next is real life, and this album has it too.

It’s full of romance, rainy day music, good for reflection, and even post-breakup meltdowns or whatever emotive tone you’re feeling. I’m looking at you in particular Alone with Me and I’m With You. So much heat there.

And that’s not to say there isn’t some fun in there. Saturday Sun is a great upbeat track and has good accompaniment with One of These Days showing up later. These are simple love songs, rooted in the tradition of artists like John Mayer, Jack Johnson and Ed Sheeran, and while they aren’t perfect, there is a cohesive quality that works, especially with the theme.

Pros: A solid theme, some great singles that stick to Joy’s strengths, and solid transitions between tracks, help this album feel like a complete story.

Cons: Sometimes the naivety can be a bit much, and this is where Crashing Into You would be considered a weak point. Some of the worst lyrics I’ve heard so far this year.

Runtime: 45 minutes

Points of Interest: Joy has been known to work with multiple writers, and in this case the running theme is evident throughout. The song Little Boy, is a true story about the time Joy fell off his bike as a little boy.

A welcome change from the never-ending mire of romantic crooners singing about falling in love, passionate sex, and breakups, this is an album for the long-time lovers. It’s never particularly cheesy, but it always feels sincere.

theories Summarized

I don’t expect that this will be an album for everyone, and as much as I wish that were the case (because the theme is strong), Vance Joy still has some growing to do as a musician, and so it bleeds together in the end. Give it a listen, be aware of the narrative, and have some forgiveness on hand, and I have a theory that you’ll enjoy yourself.

And if that don’t tickle your fancy, Brendon and I have a rock review from a brilliant Canadian duo known as Death from Above (formerly Death from Above 1979). The Physical World is also their sophomore album, and it kicks up everything fans of the band love. If you haven’t gotten into their sound yet, here is your opportunity to give them a much deserved listen.

Thanks for taking the time to read the review, watch the video review and hopefully you’ve left a comment or two. If you liked what you saw, click on the like button, and even better, subscribe to the channel! Come back tomorrow for a film review about Thor: Ragnarok. There’ll be more theories!

Tim!